Two Point Made Eyeliners, Two Different Looks
ONE/SIZE by Patrick Starrr offers two high-performance eyeliners under the Point Made name: a waterproof liquid pen and a 24-hour gel pencil. Both are vegan, paraben-free, gluten-free, and cruelty-free, but they serve different purposes. The liquid pen delivers a crisp, matte, waterproof line that won't fade or smudge, while the gel pencil combines silky application with a smudgy, kohl-like texture that can be blended or sharpened to a precise point.
Choosing between them depends on whether you want a sharp, set-and-forget wing or a softer, smokier line that can double as an eyeshadow base. Here's how they compare on the details that matter most.
Point Made Eyeliners at a Glance
- Point Made Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen: This true matte & waterproof liquid eyeliner glides on like a dream to create precise lines that won't fade, flake, bleed, or smudge. The liquid pen is designed for all-day precision without touch-ups, ideal for sharp wings or graphic liner looks.

Point Made Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen - Point Made 24-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil: A 24-hour, waterproof, and ultra-pigmented gel eyeliner that combines the silky application of a liquid liner with the smudgy texture of kohl. The gel pencil offers versatility: you can smudge it for a smoky eye or sharpen it for a defined line, and it lasts up to 24 hours.

Point Made 24-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil
Key Differences: Liquid Pen vs. Gel Pencil
- Finish: The liquid pen gives a true matte finish. The gel pencil has a creamy, slightly glossy finish that can be smudged.
- Dry-down time: The liquid pen sets in about 15 seconds. The gel pencil sets in about 10 seconds, giving you a bit more time to blend if desired.
- Application style: The liquid pen is best for stamping along the lash line and drawing precise lines. The gel pencil is designed to stay close to the lash line and can be extended into a wing or smudged with a brush.
- Wear time: The liquid pen is waterproof and promises no flaking or smudging. The gel pencil is also waterproof and claims 24-hour wear.
- Tools required: The liquid pen needs no additional tools. The gel pencil can be used alone or with a smudging brush (sold separately) for a smoky look.
How to Choose Based on Your Eye Look
If you want a sharp, graphic wing that stays put all day without touch-ups, the Point Made Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen is your pick. Its felt-tip applicator allows you to stamp and draw precise lines, and the matte finish means no shine. It's also a good choice for oily eyelids when paired with a setting powder or primer, as the brand recommends.
If you prefer a smoky, blended liner or want a product that can double as an eyeshadow base, the Point Made 24-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil offers more flexibility. You can smudge it with a dense brush for a diffused look or sharpen it for a crisp line. The brand suggests using it as a base for eyeshadows by applying in small sections and blending as you go.
Color Options and Size
- Point Made Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen: Available in Bodacious Black, Busty Brown, and Bossy Blue. The liquid pen offers a blue option for a bolder color pop, giving you more variety if you want a colorful liner.
- Point Made 24-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil: Available in Bodacious Black and Busty Brown, net weight 1.2 g / 0.04 oz. The gel pencil is limited to black and brown, but the smaller size may be easier to control for precise lining.
Honest Trade-Offs
The liquid pen's waterproof formula is excellent for longevity, but if you have oily eyelids, the brand recommends using a setting powder or primer underneath to prevent feathering. The gel pencil is more forgiving for smudging and blending, but it requires sharpening before each use to maintain a precise tip. Neither product has a built-in smudger, so if you want a smoky look with the gel pencil, you'll need a separate brush.
Both eyeliners are vegan and free of parabens and gluten, but the ingredient lists differ. The liquid pen contains nano-sized Black 2 (CI 77266), while the gel pencil may contain iron oxides and ferric ferrocyanide. If you have sensitivities, check the full ingredient lists provided by the brand.


